Sister Bay Rental Properties

Cottage, Cabin and Vacation Resorts in Sister Bay

Located on the NorthWest portion of the Door Peninsula in Door County, Sister Bay is a small village with a population of less than 1,000 people. Sister Bay is a picturesque Wisconsin village and is also home to Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant, a must stop for those visiting Door County. Browse our Sister Bay cottages, cabins and rental homes below and book your vacation today!

Country Lane Home

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 4, Queen, Queen, Queen, Queen Bathroom: 2.5, Full w/ shower/tub combo, Full w/ shower only Max Occupancy: 8...Read More→

42.5
TBA

Bumpfy Hill

Location:  Sister Bay, Beach Road Bedrooms:  4, Queen, Queen, Queen, 2 Twin Bathrooms:   5, 1 w/ Shower/Tub combo, 4 w/ Shower only...Read More→

45
See Pricing in Description

Marina View 104

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, King Master w/ private bath, Two Queen, King Bathroom: 2 Full, 1 with shower stall only, 1...Read More→

32
See Pricing in Description

Mill Road Place #3

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, King, Queen Bathroom: 2, Full with Shower Stalls only Max Occupancy: 4 Pets: No Satellite/Cable: Yes Internet:...Read More→

22
See Pricing in Description

Mill Road Place #2

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, King, Queen with twin trundle Bathroom: 2, Full with Shower Stalls only Max Occupancy: 5 Pets: No...Read More→

22
See Pricing in Description

Mill Road Place #4

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, King, Queen, plus day bed w/ trundle in lower level Bathroom: 3, All full bathrooms with shower...Read More→

23
See Pricing in Description

Marina View 201

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, King Master w/ private bath, Two Queen, King Bathroom: 2 Full, 1 with shower stall only, 1...Read More→

32
See Pricing in Description

Mill Road Place #1

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, King, Queen, plus futon in lower level Bathroom: 3, All full bathrooms with shower stall only Max...Read More→

23
See Pricing in Description

Sister Bay View

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, Queen, Full + Twin Bunk Bathroom: 1 (shower/tub combo Max Occupancy: 5 Pets: No Satellite/Cable: Yes Internet: Yes,...Read More→

21
$250/Day

Salinsky’s Domicile Cottage

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 1, Queen on second floor, plus Queen sofa sleeper on first floor Bathroom: 1, Shower stall only on...Read More→

11
TBA

Door in the Woods

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, Queen, Queen, Two Twin Bathroom: 2 Full, 1 with shower stall only, 1 with Tub/Shower combo Max...Read More→

32
TBA

Eagle Sands Beach Lodge

Location:  Sister Bay, Sand Bay Bedrooms:  3, King, Queen, Two Twins and Full Futon, plus Trundle and Queen Futon in Loft Bathrooms:  ...Read More→

32.5
See pricing in description

Another Thyme

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 4, Queen, Full, Full, and 4 Twins Bathrooms: 3, Full with Shower, Full with Shower, Full with Tub only ...Read More→

42
$475/Day

Lakeview Lodge

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, King, Queen, Queen, plus queen sofa sleeper in living room Bathroom: 2 (Full baths, 1 Comb, 1...Read More→

32
TBA

Copper Moon Cottage

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 2, King, Bunk Beds (Full/Single), Pullout Queen Sleeper Sofa Bathroom: 2, 1 Shower/Tub, 1 Shower Max Occupancy: 7...Read More→

22
See Pricing in Description

Port New

Location: Sister Bay (1 block to town ) Bedrooms: 3, Queen, Queen, 2 Twin plus Queen Futon in Loft Bathroom: 2 Max...Read More→

32
See Pricing in Description

Cappy Cottage

Location:  Sister Bay (North Bay) Bedrooms:  2, Master King, Four Twin (bunk beds) Bathrooms:   1 Max Occupancy:   6 No Smoking Pets: No...Read More→

21
See Pricing in Description

Trillium Lane

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, King, Queen, Double Bathroom: 2.5 Max Occupancy: 6 No Smoking Pets: Yes, (Small Dog only) Satellite/Cable: Yes...Read More→

32.5
See Pricing in Description

Shadow Lawn

Location:  Sister Bay (Beach Road) Bedrooms:  6 plus Chidren’s Bunk House w/ 8 twins 1 Queen, 2 twin, 2 twin, 1 double...Read More→

65.5
See Pricing in Description

Appleport Sunrise

Location: Sister Bay(Rowley’s Bay) Bedrooms: 2, king, Full/Twin bunk with Twin Trundle Bathroom: 1 Max Occupancy: 6 No Smoking Pets: No Satellite/Cable:...Read More→

21
See Pricing in Description

Abode on Spring Road

Location:  Sister Bay Bedrooms:  4,  Queen, Queen, Full, and 3 Twin Bathrooms:   2, Shower/Tub main level, Shower only upstairs Max Occupancy:    9...Read More→

42
See Pricing in Description

Wall to Wall Retreat

Location:  Sister Bay Bedrooms:  5 (king, queen, queen, 2 twins, 2 twins + crib) plus 2 queen Murphy Beds Bathrooms:  3 Maximum...Read More→

53
See Pricing in Description

A Pearl

Location:  Sister Bay, Beach Road Bedrooms:  3, King, Queen,Twin w/ trundle, Two Twin sleeper chairs Bathrooms:   2.5 Max Occupancy:    10 No...Read More→

32.5
See Pricing in Description

The Nest

Location: Sister Bay  Bedrooms: 2, Queen, Full + Twin Bunk, plus Full Futon in Living Room Bathroom: 1.5 (shower only) Max Occupancy: 8...Read More→

21.5
See Pricing in Description

Highgarden

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 3, King, Queen, Queen Bathroom: 2 (Full baths, 1 Comb, 1 shower only) Max Occupancy: 6 No Smoking Pets:...Read More→

32
See Pricing in Description

East Haven

Location: Sister Bay(Sand Bay) Bedrooms: 3, Queen, Queen, Twin + Twin w/ trundle Bathrooms: 2, 1 w/ Shower/Tub, 1 with Shower only Max Occupancy: 7-8 No Smoking Pets: Yes,...Read More→

32
See Pricing in Description

Kings Landing

We invite you, your family, friends, and PETS to come stay at our newly renovated home. We fell in love with this property located in the heart of Sister Bay late last year and are excited to be a part of Door County.

43.5
See Pricing in Description

Hidden Gem

Location: Sister Bay Bedrooms: 4, King, Queen, Queen, Two Twin Bathroom: 3, Full w/ Bathtub Only, Full w/ Shower Only, Full w/ Shower Only Max...Read More→

43
See Pricing in Description

Resthaven (formerly Le Jardin)

Location:  Sister Bay, Beach Road Bedrooms:  5, Queen, Queen, Two Twin, Two Twin, and Full w/ Twin Bunk on third floor Bathrooms:  ...Read More→

52.5
See Pricing in Description